Dutch investors want clarity on carbon credits as tech and energy dominate
With global warming exceeding 1.5°C targets, a group of Dutch investors stress the need for clarity on carbon credits
A group of Dutch investors, featuring pension giant PGGM, investment manager Achmea and insurer a.s.r, have set out their principles around the use of carbon credits, removal and storage, stressing that carbon credits should never be used to compensate for a lack of emissions reductions. However, the organisations do see a role for strategies to remove emissions.
Longview Networks Insurance Investment Forum | 20 January 2027 | London
"Direct emissions reductions remain non-negotiable. At the same time, we must invest today in the high-quality carbon removals that the world will need over the longer term. With these principles, we make clear, together with Achmea and ASR, how both tracks can progress in parallel, without allowing carbon credits to become an excuse for delaying necessary emissions reductions," said Jeroen Rijk, head of Total Portfolio Management at PGGM.
The three organisations have set out three core principles to guide corporates' use of credits or carbon removal, arguing that such approaches should always be complementary, rather than a substitute, focused on high-quality credits, and accounted for separately from emissions disclosures.
Firms should also be clear on the purpose of specific credits bought and progressively shift towards carbon removals with an increasing degree of permanence, the investors say.
Finally, corporates should provide full transparency and traceability, from purchase to final retirement.
Their appeal comes as the carbon credit market remains dominated by the energy sector, with Shell remaining the single biggest retirer of carbon credits by volume: the energy giant retired 14.5 million credits in 2024. At the same time, the firm scrapped its 2035 carbon intensity target and weakened its 2030 goal in March 2024, and its 2026 energy transition strategy abandoned the 2035 target again and watered down the 2030 goal further. Shell also continues to expand its LNG production.
In the carbon removals space, Microsoft holds a dominant role: the tech giant bought 93 per cent of all carbon removal credits in 2025, according to Bloomberg NEF. Meanwhile, the firm's emissions grew by 25 per cent in 2025 to 34 million tonnes, driven by AI data centre expansion.